Economic Updates
Stay up-to-date on economic conditions and outlook with our analysis and commentary.
Economic Update – Second Quarter 2013
Review and Outlook
This past quarter was a very interesting one. The quarter that ended on June 30, 2013 was not as strong as the one that preceded it, but the Dow Jones Industrial Average (Dow) still posted a 2.3% gain. The Dow is up 13.8% for the first six months, which is the best first-half showing for the index since 1999. These strong results were in spite of all the economic and political issues we’ve faced during that time. In fact, at the beginning of the year, predicting double-digit gains for the first 6 months didn’t even seem possible!
Let’s see where we are today at the midway point of 2013:
Recently, several major issues surfaced, including: tax increases, the federal sequester, problems in China and other emerging markets, the recession in Europe, the Fed’s recent talk about tightening monetary policy and the ensuing rise in interest rates. Despite these issues, some recent data tells us that the economy is still doing well.
Quantitative Easing
A major reason for the improvement in the economy and the stock market is the unconventional measures and policies implemented by the Federal Reserve since the financial crisis. Since late 2008, the Fed has kept the federal funds rate close to 0%, and promises to keep it at historically low levels until the unemployment rate falls to 6.5% and as long as inflation remains under 2%. In addition, the Fed has implemented three rounds of Quantitative Easing (QE)—printing money in order to buy large amounts of assets from the market. They are currently buying at a rate of $85 billion per month, mainly mortgage-backed securities and longer-term Treasuries.
QE boosts the prices of the purchased assets and reduces their interest rates. This helps the economy in general by driving down borrowing costs, pushing up asset prices and therefore encourages more investing, spending and hiring. The Fed recently restated the idea that it could taper off those purchases going forward, depending on economic conditions—if growth picks up or unemployment comes down, the Fed said it could start the “wind-down” of the QE program later this year, and possibly stop buying bonds altogether by the middle of next year. (Source: WSJ, June 20, 2013)
June showed a strong unemployment report—195,000 new jobs, which was well over the predicted 166,000. Was this enough to encourage the Fed to stay on this course?
The financial markets have currently been fixated and dependent on monetary policies therefore the markets did not react favorably to these comments. Merely the threat of limiting QE swiftly sent bond prices down and yields soaring since early May. Fed officials recently reassured investors that they aren’t going to bring their monetary policy to an abrupt halt. (WSJ, June 20, 2013)
Of course, it’s possible that investors overreacted to Ben Bernanke’s recent statements. He’s said the same thing before—that the Fed will adjust its monthly bond purchases depending on the economic data. Right now the numbers don’t justify reducing monthly bond purchases, but that could change in only a few months. Bernanke expects the Fed won’t raise short-term interest rates until some time after the unemployment rate hits 6.5%, which would be more than a full percentage point lower than its current level.
The Economy
On a positive note, it appears lately the economy has shown indications that it is still expanding, even if only at a modest pace. In addition, Mr. Bernanke also stated that the risks to the economy were diminishing. Last year, Fed policymakers were worried that Europe’s financial market and fiscal woes would affect the U.S. Also, many investors are concerned about the impact of U.S. tax increases and spending cuts. They are now less worried about Europe and encouraged that the U.S. economy has held up and stocks have performed solidly despite fiscal headwinds at home. Still, Europe’s contraction has affected exports, and corporate growth has suffered, keeping U.S. growth too sluggish for the Fed to trim monetary easing by much or to justify much higher market interest rates.
In fact, the main concern for many economists is not inflation and an over-heated economy, but the possibility of deflation and a stall in growth. While the economy adjusted well to the fiscal tightening earlier this year, a continuing rise in interest rates or decline in stock prices would trim growth.
What lies ahead for investors in the second half of this year? We made some progress on unemployment and shrinking the Federal deficit, but the economic recovery is still fragile, and we still have to deal with the debt limit. One of the key factors will be corporate earnings.
The headlines in recent weeks have been filled with scandals and controversies that have sharply divided the American public including:
- The U.S. government appears to be spying on its citizens and even on our allies.
- The IRS appears to have unfairly targeted special interest groups.
Regardless of where you stand on these issues, it is important to remember several historical events that we have just commemorated the 150th anniversary of the battle at Gettysburg and the birth of our nation 237 years ago. During these times in our country’s history, we have faced and overcome far greater obstacles, both political and economic, than those in the news today.
Interest Rates
Interest rates have been rising rapidly since Ben Bernanke mentioned in late May that the Fed’s asset-buying could possibly come to an end this year. In a month, long-term mortgage rates jumped from about 3.7% to 4.5%, and there is plenty of reason to believe that rates might continue to rise. This increase has caused a sharp decline in the refinancing of existing mortgages, as well as fewer new loans being put on the books. That means less cash for consumers from their home equity and lower overall demand going forward.
The Federal Open Market Committee voted 10-2 on June 19, 2013 to keep short-term interest rates unchanged for a 36th consecutive meeting. It has now been four and a half years since the Fed made any change to short-term rates. (Source: Federal Reserve, June 24, 2013)
The Bond Market
After a three-decade bond bull market and half a decade of unprecedented Central Bank intervention, bond yields entered 2013 near all-time lows and the first four months of the year still produced further price gains. Unfortunately, if you’ve looked at your bond portfolio lately, you’re painfully aware of what has happened since. The yield on the 10-year Treasury note, which had fallen to 1.6% on May 2, 2013, stood at 2.175% as of June 14, 2013. (Source: Barron’s, June 17, 2013)
Many bond investors probably guessed they could end up hurting this year, but they probably didn’t anticipate the suffering of the last couple months. Many investors were shocked by the speed and scope of the resulting losses. The worst part was that some of the biggest declines came in parts of the markets traditionally viewed as safe but offering higher yields, such as municipal bonds and dividend-paying stocks. When interest rates rise, bond prices usually fall.
Many investors believe that Treasuries in particular still look very expensive, although it’s hard to imagine that yields could go anywhere but up. Many economists believe that the bond market will not burst any time soon, since the Federal Reserve is committed to holding interest rates down for about two more years. The intention is for the market change to resemble not so much a popped bubble as a gradually melting block of ice.
How can an investor potentially reduce the potential damage of rising interest rates on a bond portfolio? Some ideas include:
- Focusing on bond durations. The greater the duration, the more the value will change with changes in the interest rate.
- Consider investing in Treasury Inflation Protected Securities (TIPS). These values and interest rates will change depending on the inflation rate.
Equities
Despite the recent rise in volatility and dip in stock prices, it appears the bull market in U.S. equities is far from over. The pullbacks in bonds, emerging markets, and metals have been sharper and swifter than the drop in the broad U.S. stock market. Many investors had actually been hoping for a correction so they could catch up to the stock market’s rally, but had second thoughts as interest rates spiked too sharply, emerging markets went reeling, and worst of all the Federal Reserve talked about ending its monetary program.
Equity investors are still not sure what to make of the rise in bond yields. On the one hand, the drop in bond prices (and corresponding rise in yields) could represent a response to the prospect of faster economic growth, which in turn would hopefully bring with it stronger corporate revenues and profits. On the other hand, faster growth would also decrease the need for Federal Reserve bond buying, which is now approaching the $2 trillion mark and has been a huge boost for the stock market. Naturally, investors fear that withdrawal of that liquidity, in whole or in part, will adversely impact stocks. (Source: The Complete Investor, June 3, 2013)
Volatility
When many investors think of risk, one thing comes to mind: volatility. Increasingly, however, it appears that short-term risk and volatility don’t matter as much as the permanent loss of capital. Remember this: volatility is not the same as risk, because all historical declines have been temporary, while the advance of equity values has been permanent. Volatility can pass but the returns stay. Some of the long-term risk of owning equities is beyond volatility prices and the global economy; it is in the emotional impact on investors. Unfortunately, many investors view a significant temporary decline as the onset of some apocalypse. Therefore, one of the dominant factors in long-term, real-life financial outcomes is investor behavior. (Source: Nick Murray Interactive, November 2012)
While volatile times can be rough on investors, communicating with your financial advisor can help keep you focused on your goals.
Inflation
The Consumer Price Index was up only 1.2% in the first quarter from a year earlier, which is well below the Central Bank’s target. It was the weakest annual reading since the third quarter of 2008. The Fed has a 2% inflation goal and doesn’t want consumer prices to veer too much above or below that number. Seeing inflation below the Fed’s 2% target creates a nagging worry. While such low inflation is acceptable in an expanding economy, if recession strikes, there isn’t much distance to cover before prices fall. This could push the economy into a deflationary trap.
Although some Fed officials seem eager to start tapering off the Fed’s bond purchases, given such low inflation, any reduction will likely be gradual. In fact, if inflation should go even lower, then the Fed has considered an increase in bond purchases, rather than a reduction.
Gold
Stocks and bonds aren’t the only investments under pressure lately. The current market turmoil has pushed gold to its lowest level in two and a half years. Since closing at an all-time high of $1,888 per ounce on August 22, 2011, the price of gold has fallen 36% down to $1,201 per ounce on June 27, 2013. Although gold could fall further, in the near time, many economists believe that the downside risk is limited. (Source: CME Group)
Real Estate
Housing had good news this quarter. Although housing prices fell 3.2% in June, that followed a strong month in May when home prices came in 12.2% higher than they were a year ago. New home sales also recorded a strong increase following mid-June’s increase in existing home sales. Even with foreclosures for sale on the market, new home sales are still more competitive. Pending home sales also increased sharply. In fact, the index is at its highest level since 2006. We’ll have to see if the recent increase in mortgage interest rates slows housing activity, but history shows it usually doesn’t as long as the economic growth continues and the rate increases aren’t too sharp. (Source: Retirement Watch, June 27, 2013)
As we previously noted, the average rate on a 30-year mortgage rose significantly from May to June, and refinancing applications were down. While many lenders had predicted that refinancing would taper off, not many anticipated that the move in rates would happen so quickly and intensely. Even so, some buyers are still trying to take advantage of mortgage rates that, despite the increase, remain historically low.
Some investors are worried that Mr. Bernanke’s plans could hurt the housing market by driving up mortgage rates. Many economists believe that the Fed has created an artificially low mortgage rate. However, the housing industry depends on that below-average mortgage rate, and the housing recovery would most likely slow down without it.
Conclusion
The interest rate moves highlight the difficult task facing the Fed. Fed officials may want to start pulling back on their bond buying program soon, but they communicated that they want to do it in a gradual way that won’t send short-term interest rates up too quick. This could prove to be a delicate task, since investors have already shown just how sensitive they are to even hints of a small adjustment.
Few economists expect the stock market to repeat its first-half results in the second half of this year because investors are simply too uncertain about the actions of the central banks, and the Federal Reserve in particular. Still, many economists prefer U.S. stocks to almost any alternative. After all, bonds are plunging, gold is tarnished, and many emerging markets are no longer emerging.
The bottom line is this: It’s complicated. We have a huge economy ($16 trillion covering 330 million people) and we feel the impact of not just our own actions but other economies all over the globe. We face problems for which there are no easy solutions, and no good way to predict the changes that are surely coming in the future. (Source: Bob LeClair’s Newsletter, June 29, 2013)
As we said earlier, it is still best to work with your advisor to put together a strategy that you’re comfortable with and to stay focused. Try not to let the media get you riled up with every new statement, scandal or economic sign, because that kind of emotion can be the biggest risk to investors. As always, we’re happy to review your portfolio with you to make sure you have a balance of investments that is appropriate for your current situation.
Note: The views stated in this article are not necessarily the opinion of FSC Securities Corporation and should not be construed, directly or indirectly, as an offer to buy or sell any securities mentioned herein. Investors should be aware that there are risks inherent in all investments, such as fluctuations in investment principal. With any investment vehicle, past performance is not a guarantee of future results. Material discussed herewith is meant for general illustration and/or informational purposes only, please note that individual situations can vary. Therefore, the information should be relied upon when coordinated with individual professional advice. This material contains forward looking statements and projections. There are no guarantees that these results will be achieved. There is no guarantee that a diversified portfolio will outperform a non-diversified portfolio in any given market environment. Due to volatility within the markets mentioned, opinions are subject to change without notice. Information is based on sources believed to be reliable; however, their accuracy or completeness cannot be guaranteed. Indexes cannot be invested in directly, are unmanaged and do not incur management fees, costs or expenses. No investment strategy, such as asset allocation and rebalancing, can guarantee a profit or protect against loss in periods of declining values. In general, the bond market is volatile, bond prices rise when interest rates fall and vice versa. This effect is usually pronounced for longer-term securities. Any fixed income security sold or redeemed prior to maturity may be subject to a substantial gain or loss. The investor should note that investments in lower-rated debt securities (commonly referred to as junk bonds) involve additional risks because of the lower credit quality of the securities in the portfolio. The investor should be aware of the possible higher level of volatility, and increased risk of default. The payment of dividends is not guaranteed. Companies may reduce or eliminate the payment of dividends at any given time. International investing involves special risks including greater economic and political instability, as well as currency fluctuation risks, which may be even greater in emerging markets. The price of commodities is subject to substantial price fluctuations of short periods of time and may be affected by unpredictable international monetary and political policies. The market for commodities is widely unregulated and concentrated investing may lead to higher price volatility.
Sources: Wall Street Journal (4/29/13, 6/14/13,6/20/13, 7/5/13, 7/6-7/13, 7/10/13, 7/12/13), Retirement Watch (6/27/13), Barron’s (6/17/13, 7/1/13), Dow Theory Forecast (7/1/13), Money Magazine (5/2013), The Complete Investor (6/3/13), By The Numbers (6/24/13), Kiplinger’s Personal Finance (6/2013), Bob LeClair’s Personal Finance (6/29/13, 7/6/13), Nick Murray Interactive (11/2012) Contents Provided by MDP, Inc. Copyright 2013 MDP Inc.
Housing Market – 3rd Quarter Update
Home prices snatched their strongest gains since 2005, climbing 5.9% from January through July and signaling the housing market’s steady trudge toward recovery. For the broader economy, the turn in housing could provide a much-needed boost if it continues.
Rising prices could eventually lift consumer spending if homeowners begin to feel wealthier again. Housing construction, a big generator of jobs, also has the potential to play a major role in economic growth. (Source: WSJ, September 26, 2012, A1 Housing Market Displays)
Rising prices largely reflect a dwindling number of foreclosed homes being sold by banks as well as stronger demand for those properties from investors.Foreclosures and other “distressed” homes typicallysell at larger discounts, and with fewer of those properties selling, prices are under less pressure. The median sales price for new homes in August was $256,900, up 17% from a year ago, and the highest level since December 2004. (Source: Bob LeClair’s, September 15, 2012)
Rising demand, especially at the low end, is putting upward pressure on prices as traditional buyers, as opposed to investors, feel more confident about jumping into the market.
Quantitative Easing – Ciccarelli 3rd Quarter Update
Federal chairman Ben Bernanke announced in September that the Central Bank will begin buying $40 billion of mortgage-backed securities per month starting in October and will continue to do so until the unemployment picture starts to show improvement. This is the Fed’s third round of quantitative easing (QE3) since the 2008 panic with a goal of further reducing long-term interest rates. (Source: WSJ, September 14, 2012, A12 Bernanke Unbounded) Recently, Mr. Bernanke extended the Fed’s forecast for near-zero interest rates until the middle of 2015. His plan also includes continuing “Operation Twist,” which exchanges short-term securities for those with longer maturities.
The Fed wants to continue pursuing its “dual mandate” of controlling inflation and reducing unemployment. “We have to do more, and we’ll do enough to make sure the economy gets on the right track,” Mr. Bernanke declared.
We still have not yet felt all of the ripple effects of these new policies, but one of them is the risk of future inflation, which Mr. Bernanke stated hasn’t strayed too far above the Fed’s 2% “core inflation” target. Unfortunately, this ignores the increase in food and energy prices, which consumers pay even if the Fed discounts them in its “core” calculations.
After three decades of decline, many investment advisors believe rates could be on their way back up soon. Pinpointing the timing of an interest rate rise is difficult, if not impossible. After the global economic crisis in 2008, many investors flooded into U.S. Treasury bonds, which consequently pushed their yields down. Unfortunately, if interest rates start increasing, the value of many bonds will decrease.
There are several potential drivers of higher interest rates. One might be inflation. While it has been fairly tame for years, if commodity prices and other costs start to climb, inflation could begin to creep higher. A consequence of higher inflation is typically higher interest rates
The Fiscal Cliff – Quarterly Update
The term “fiscal cliff” was coined by the Federal Reserve chairman Ben Bernanke, and refers to the $550 billion in tax hikes and spending cuts that will take place automatically on January 1, 2013, unless the President and Congress take action to prevent it. (Source: Kiplinger’s Personal Finance, October 2012)
Failure to modify the tax hikes and spending cuts would almost certainly induce a recession. The Tax Policy Center estimates that the fiscal cliff would hit 90% of U.S. taxpayers and cost an average of $3,500 in extra taxes per household. (Source: USA Today, October 5, 2012, 5B Investing Protect Your Money)
The fiscal cliff itself isn’t giving money managers nearly as much reason to worry as the uncertainty surrounding it is. “Uncertainty is worse than knowing,” said Leo Grohowski, chief investment officer at BNY Mellon Wealth Management. (Source: Investment News, July 16, 2012, page 34) The most uncertainty surrounds dividends, which have been increasingly popular, given the record low yields in fixed income, Mr. Grohowski said. Right now, the dividend tax rate is at 15%, but depending on what Congress decides, it could go as high as 43% for that bracket. “That’s a pretty big spread of uncertainty,” Mr. Grohowski said.
Unless Democrats and Republicans can agree to extend at least some of the Bush-era tax cuts or postpone some of the spending cuts mandated by the Budget Control Act passed last year, the economy will suffer. “The macroeconomics behind the fiscal cliff issue is horrendous,” said Allen Sinai, chief global economist with consultant Decision Economics, Inc. “It’s unthinkable that this might actually happen.” (Source: Investment News, July 16, 2012, page 34)
Many advisors believe Congress will take steps to moderate some, if not all, of the tax changes before the end of the year. However, even if they don’t, they could still pass laws next year retroactive to the beginning of 2013. Unfortunately, with all the uncertainty still looming today, markets are likely to be swayed by the headlines rather than fundamentals.
The mere threat of $600 billion in tax hikes and spending cuts is already delaying business spending. Big economic forces, both domestic and abroad, are combining to dampen growth. As the economy has cooled, so have the economists’ forecasts. The average estimate of the 79 economists surveyed by Bloomberg is for gross domestic product to rise 2.1% in 2013, down from the consensus of 2.5% in May. The fiscal cliff poses the biggest threat. The combination of deep spending cuts and tax increases set to hit in January could strip as many as four percentage points off 2013 GDP growth. On top of that, the global economy is weakening, particularly in China and Europe, two of the biggest export markets for the U.S. China’s industrial output is growing at its slowest pace since May 2009. Although Europe’s leaders appear to be making progress in taming their debt crisis, much of the continent is already in recession. (Source: Bloomberg, September 17-23, 2012, page 13)
Global trade is stalling, dimming prospects that exports will buoy the U.S. economy in the coming months. The World Trade Organization just projected the global volume of trade in goods would expand only 2.5% this year, down from 5% last year and nearly 14% growth in 2010. The trade slowdown could worsen as momentum slips across the global economy.
Europe was the epicenter of the weakness radiating from the global economy. Weak exports have exacerbated a slowdown in China’s domestic economy, which economists project will grow about 7.5% this year, which would be the weakest annual expansion since 1990. (Source: WSJ, October 1, 2012, A1 Trade Slows)
Third Quarter Economic Update 2012
Wow – talk about another interesting quarter in the stock market! The Dow Jones Industrial Average rose 4.3% during the third quarter and is up 10.0% through September
30, 2012. The S&P 500 is having an even stronger year, with a 5.8% rise during the third quarter and a 14.6% gain year-to-date. The NASDAQ also had a great quarter, increasing 6.17% and 19.6% year-todate. There are many forces driving these gains:
- Many analysts believe that the Federal Reserve’s efforts to inject money into the financial system will help asset prices continue to go higher.
- Rising dividends are another source of support forthe stock market as many investors continue to reinvest the proceeds. For example, in August,S&P 500 companies paid out a record $34 billionin dividends. (Source: WSJ, October 1, 2012, C1 US Stock Investors Look Beyond)
- Stepped-up efforts to aid the Euro zone, such as the European Central Bank’s plan to buy government debt to reduce some nations’ borrowing costs, gave many investors confidence to take on more risk, according to many analysts. The Federal Reserve’s September 13, 2012, announcement of new stimulus measures for the U.S. economy also helped in this regard. To the surprise of many investors, many U.S. stockshave nearly come full circle and are going into the finalquarter of this year within shouting distance of all-timehighs. Five years ago on October 9th, the Dow JonesIndustrial Average closed at an all-time high of14,164.53. As of Friday, October 5, 2012, the Dow closed less than 4% below its peak. (Source: WSJ,October 6-7, 2012, B7 What A Trip)
Let’s look at what happened during this five-year period: the stock market halved and then doubled; bonds soared; the real-estate market crashed, then stabilized, and is possibly on its way back; and energy prices spiked, tanked and rose back, too. During this time, the U.S. government racked up massive new debts, and many other global economies also experienced significant changes in their economic pictures.
The 37% drop in the S&P 500 in 2008 was devastating for investors, but since then the stock market has yielded annual returns of 26.46%, 15.06%, and 2.05%. Dividend yield on the S&P 500 has also been steady at slightly above 2%. Many investors who left their money in the market are now ahead of where they were at the end of 2008. Unfortunately, many investors who wanted to keep their money “safe” are shaking their heads as to what to do now. (Source: Bob LeClair’s Newsletter, September 15, 2012)
No one knows whether stocks and bonds will continue to climb or will hit a steep drop, but either way several experts constantly remind us that two important things to consider are:
- It is difficult to consistently time the market,
- and
- Diversify, diversify, diversify!
Many investors are worried about risks looming on the horizon—everything from key fiscal issues in the U.S. to the global economic outlook. The debt crisis in Europe remains unresolved and its economy is stagnating. In the U.S., earnings forecasts have also been reduced. With the presidential election only a few weeks away, major political uncertainty hangs over the U.S., especially when it comes to the Fiscal Cliff, when some very critical economic stimulus measures expire.
With all of these uncertainties, how has the market continued to do so well? There are a number of reasons. “International investors have used the U.S. stock market as a safe haven,” says Lisa Shalett, chief investment officer at Bank of American Merrill Lynch Global Wealth Management. “They see it as a much better place to have been around the world than emerging markets, which have struggled, and a better place to be than Europe.” (Source: WSJ, October 1, 2012, C1 US Stock Investors Look Beyond)